Many Atlanta landlords focus on monthly rent, but real success comes down to one number, that being your return on investment (ROI). It’s the only way to see whether your property is building wealth or just breaking even.
ROI reveals your rental’s profitability after accounting for the real costs: maintenance, vacancy, property taxes, management, and appreciation over time.
Here’s how to calculate your rental ROI step-by-step instead of guessing what your property is really earning.
Here’s the simple formula every Atlanta landlord should know:
ROI = (Net Annual Income ÷ Total Investment) × 100
Net Annual Income: Rent collected minus expenses (taxes, insurance, maintenance, management, and vacancy).
Total Investment: Down payment + closing costs + renovations or repairs.
That means you’re earning about 5 cents for every dollar you’ve invested each year.
💡 Tip: Most investors aim for 6–8% ROI in metro Atlanta for a healthy balance between income, appreciation, and risk.
To calculate ROI accurately, you need to include the expenses that quietly shrink profit margins.
Vacancy: One month vacant equals an 8% annual income loss, about $2,000 gone on a $2,000/month home. For many owners, that single gap wipes out a year’s margin.
Maintenance: Plan for 1–2% of your property’s value each year, especially for older homes in areas like Decatur or East Atlanta.
Management Fees: Professional management typically costs 8-10% of rent, but is often offset by faster leasing and lower repair costs.
Capital Expenses: Budget for long-term replacements like roofs, HVAC, and flooring to keep ROI predictable.
Property Taxes & Insurance: Include these fixed costs in your annual projections. Rates vary by county and coverage type.
Even small underestimations can make a “great” ROI look much smaller once real costs appear.
Beyond monthly rent, real wealth comes from equity and appreciation.
If your $350,000 home appreciates 3% annually, that’s $10,500 in added value each year. Add mortgage principal reduction, and your true ROI can easily reach 8–9%, even if your cash flow ROI is only 5–6%.
Home values in Atlanta have remained generally steady, and experts expect modest movement in the coming years. Some forecasts point to mild appreciation, while others suggest flat or slightly declining trends as affordability and inventory pressures grow. That kind of stability, paired with long-term tenants, turns well-managed rentals into reliable wealth builders.
How you manage your rental can make or break your ROI. The difference between DIY and professional management often comes down to time, efficiency, and hidden costs.
Self-managing your property can seem like a way to save money, but the hidden costs often tell a different story:
A professional team turns your rental into a hands-off investment that performs consistently:
Example: A DIY landlord earning 4.5% ROI could see that rise to 6.5% or higher once professional management reduces vacancy time and streamlines repairs.
Usually 6–10% annually, depending on property type, financing, and location. Higher-end homes may yield lower cash flow but offer stronger appreciation.
Yes! Appreciation and mortgage paydown are key parts of your total return, especially in steady-growth markets like Atlanta.
Revisit your numbers once a year or whenever rent, expenses, or taxes change.
Stop guessing.
See exactly what your property could earn, backed by live market data from Renters Warehouse Atlanta.
Whether your rental is in Midtown, Decatur, Sandy Springs, or East Atlanta, our team will show you how your home compares to similar listings and what your true ROI could be with professional management.
Get Your Free Rental Analysis
Understand your property’s ROI before your next tenant moves in and make every dollar work harder.